Best Plumbing Services in Indianapolis, IN

This is the second time I have reviewed Paul Henderson Plumbing. Recently they replaced a garbage disposal. After looking at the bill and researching I found that they charged me twice what the disposal cost at all the local hardware stores. I complained but they said it was because the local stores get a better deal than they do. Why wouldnt they go to lowes? BI asked to have the owner call me to discuss this and I haven't heard  a word. I am very concerned that they are overcharging customers. And disappointed in Paul Henderson Plumbing.

Best customer service! Friendly and always on-time. I've had them help me multiple times. 100% satisfied with service and rates!

Tech was fast and knowledgeable.. Definitely recommend Cornwell. They did the job for only $125 where another plumber (Hope) wanted $750.

I had learned of this company through the real estate company where I work.  We have several offices and whenever there's a plumbing problem where I work from I noticed it was Mishler who came to the rescue. The company is known for doing business with qualified people...but at competitive prices.  So when a leak in my bathroom sink occurred, I decided to give them a personal try and was very pleased.  Nice plumber, right on time, and great job.  Then just recently I had a very different and more complex problem so I called them again.  Same experience - different very personal plumber, good neat work, and fair price...hence this review.  I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them.

We had a leaking hot water heater earlier this year and called several plumbers to give us quotes on a tankless system.  A couple came out to look at our situation and provide a quote on a tankless but the service tech from Indy Water Heater & Softener was THE ONLY ONE who checked the warranty on the water heater tank we had installed and let us know that the unit was still under warranty.  These guys presented us the option of replacing the unit under warranty or a tankless option - so we chose to replace the unit under warranty of course!  Everyone else was looking to close a tankless sale, so now when the time comes to actually install a tankless system I will be making one call - to Indy Water Heater & Softener.  Just last week before Christmas our garbage disposal was leaking, I didn't call the guys I have a maintenance contract with, I called these guys.  They were out quickly to replace and could not have been more professional or friendly.  I would recommend these guys to anyone with a plumbing repair need or an installation.  Great work guys!!

The best, the best, the best!  After working with them in a previous life (or marriage), when my HVAC system went belly up in my newly purchased home, I knew exactly who I wanted to handle the job.  The first tech came out to diagnose on a Tuesday and by Friday afternoon I was up and running with a new reliable Trane system.  Everyone you deal with excels in customer service, efficiency, and they aren't in the business of overselling you more than you need.

The technician was very polite and thorough. He arrived in the timeline the company quoted. The work I had done was reasonably priced.

They went to the wrong address and then texted us saying the technician left since we didn't answer the door and would have to reschedule. Well that would make sense that I didn't answer a door at a house I do not live. They did not answer when I called and texted them to say we were home, so they must be at the wrong address. The rep later called to say it is not their policy to call when the tech arrives as they give a 30 minute notice when the tech is on their way, of which I did receive and replied to. Common sense would say, it is odd when the homeowner doesn't answer their door after they just confirmed via text. We will not use this company. And based upon the company's response to another negative review, they do not hold themselves accountable at all.

Very pleased with the entire experience. They were reasonable on price, on time, and cleaned up great afterwards.  They installed a new lift pump for us. Matt was very pleasant to work with and wss done in a timely fashion.  I would highly recommend them.

Had a busted pipe in the basement that needed fixed. Guy shows up in a timely manner. Looks around at the issue for a few minutes and then asks me what I'm willing to pay????? Are you kidding me?? I said no I need a quote. He sat there for another couple minutes and then rattled off a number without taking any measurements on the pipe needing replaced or anything. The price was over double what I ended up paying from another plumbing company. I will NEVER let Roto-Rooter in my house again. Scam artists taking advantage of people in bad situations.

We needed to have our (very old) sewer line replaced. We'd received a quote from another company but wanted to bid out such a large project. Carlisle was less expensive and did a very good job. They gave us multiple options and quotes as well as their recommendations on how to proceed. The sewer was a tight squeeze between houses, trees, and our gas line. They dug it up and replaced it, as well as some additional plumbing inside to reroute a pipe without any incidents. They were very good at explaining to me what they were doing and were courteous and professional when asking me to run water to test the line. I would recommend them for future plumbing projects.

Quick response but a little less than honest when it comes to how much you actually pay them.  They really push their product as a replacement rather  than want to try to repair what you already have.  Hesitant to even try so not sure if they just want to make more money on full replacement or aren't confident in working on other brands?

Glad the rep from BFP was able to come out same day. Very disappointed they don't give estimates and disappointed that the bill was almost $400 for repairing a PVC that had broken in two separate pieces.  I understand there was around two feet of plywood cutting to reach the other end of the PVC but I'm still floored at the basic price. I was not there at the time, but when I talked to the technician on the phone to go over the bill he asked for my credit card. I told him I was next in line for a purchase and could I call him back. His response was if you don't call back in 10 minutes I'm adding another $89 to your bill. Time is money but that was unnecessary. I also did not like the fact that there was no breakdown of what I spent as far as parts and labor. The rep said there was a two year warranty, but that should be up to the customer especially if it dictates a price increase. So in a nutshell the price and customer service definitely could have been better. Recommend shopping around and getting a quote.

It's been 3 years and they still have not finished our prepaid contract. They don't remember what they promised and create more problems than solutions. For instance they gouged corners of our freshly painted walls done by another company, and that was 12 months ago. The caulk is still apparent and nothing had been done since. So our lovely paint job is waiting for them to fix it. We originally hired them to do our guest bath and the sink is too close to the wall and the cabinet cannot be opened fully, as the hardware won't allow, because it hits the wall. They hire subcontractors and do not use their own employees. During the 2 days to put in just the shower, Indy Concrete was able to install a patio and fireplace in the rain in less than a day. Indy Renovations workers took more cigarette breaks than actual work time. The shower was installed improperly as the water would pool in the middle and seal for the glass is not complete. Every shower there is stream of water coming out into the bathroom tile.
We were without floor trim for 12 months and the flooring installed was gapping at least 1/2 to 1 inch from the wall. Our front door tile grout is already in pieces and they installed metal transitions that should be in an office building. They forgot the floor transition to and from guest bathroom.  They have tried to charge us twice for the floor trim and didn't have info on the prepaid fireplace. It was only when I pulled out the contract of what we've paid for that still had not been done. Our floor trim is still unfinished after two visits as the nail holes are very visible and the pieces of trim combined have huge gaps.
We actually contracted this company in 3/2020 it's soon going to be 3/2023 and the still not finished and on their side unclear of what they were paid for. Terrified of the job they will destroy on our fireplace. DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY... It will cause you nothing but shoddy work, mishaps, and then asking you to pay for services already paid for. You will get the runaround about every aspect of the job. They will leave trash, nails, as well as their installation trash.
When will this nightmares

3/10/15 - Plumber arrived EARLY which was a relatively nice surprise...but not ideal as I was in bed when the young man arrived (7:15am). He admitted not having my phone # to call give me fair warning of his :15 early arrival.

We have a Moen Roman Tub that has a cartridge 1248B that was stuck / corroded in both the hot / cold handles. He went out to his truck and within :10 determined that his silver Moen puller wasn't long enough to reach the deep cartridge.

He offered to drive around town looking for the correct tool...but that my timer would be running until it was located. I was billed $45 for :20 visit!

After handing him my $45 check...I felt as if I just awoke from a nightmare!!

P.S. - Mr. Williams (CC Williams) plumber came over the following week, he simply screwed a long screw into the cartridge (handle) and pulled real hard with pliers...popped out each cartridge in the first :10 of his visit!!!  :)

They have provided several services for my rentals. they are on time  professional and try to work you into their schedule if its urgent. I also love that they dont try to sell you replacements when not needed but will help in maintaining function.

Larry Plumbing did some work in my house about a year ago, He was found by the contractor I hired back then and never had to deal with him personaly. Recently, I had a situation where my basement flooded due to a clogged outside drainage, although it took us some time to find, my first person to reach was Larry... here's where it gets fun, he picks up the phone and tells me that he has no interest to help out due to a bad past experience with the contractor I had when I was remodeling the house .. he then tells me to find someone else to fix my problems! This level of unprofessional customer dealing leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth and thought I would share so no one has to deal with this kind of issues in the future. I don't have anything negative to say about his job which has held fine, but definitely on his customer treatment and more on emergencies such as the one I just went through.
SS

He was the only plumber who come come within 4 hours for a leak in my garage.  I should have waited.   He did find the leak in an outside faucet and repair it.  He then takes me into cutting a vent in my furnace stack to heat my garage, then drive to a hardware store 5 minutes away to buy a vent.  He was gone almost 2 hours.  When he came back he looked at another leaking outdoor faucet and told me it was not urgent, and that he wasn't available again for 3 weeks.  He charged me almost $800, most of that labor for time he wasn't even at my home.  I called someone else a few weeks later.  The second leak caused a mold problem that had to be remediated, and the furnace vent is not to code and has to be removed.  By the way, the faucet he did repair no longer works.  What a crook!

Error: html_entity_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated
Line: 405
File: tpl-listings.php

Error: html_entity_decode(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated
Line: 405
File: tpl-listings.php