Val H.
04/05/2013 12:00:00 SA
Like many other people said, I wish I'd checked Yelp too, before I called South West Plumbing. Someone else mentioned that they must be able to afford heavy TV advertising from the EXORBITANT prices they charge. I think that's very true.
I'm a 50 year old woman, and I take care of my 87 year old mother at her house. I had originally called my husband to come from Port Townsend to Redmond to fix what I thought was a totally fried garbage disposal....I mean the thing was more than 30 years old, and wouldn't run when I flipped the switch, and I smelled a burning electrical smell. Husby told me to try pressing the reset button on the disposal, but nothing happened. He was all tied up with his work, so we decided we'd better call a plumber out to Mom's house to install a new disposal. I mean how much could it be? I expected anywhere from $200 to at most, $500 for the job. Parts and labor.
I'm pretty handy, and have done some very minor plumbing work in my lifetime, but I didn't trust myself to buy and install a new disposal. HOWEVER, I'm very knowledgable about disposal prices, because my husband recently replaced our unit in Port Townsend. We paid $99 for it. It also took him less than a half hour to install it. So my estimate of around $99 to $200 for a disposal plus labor, I figured was about right.
I looked in the phone book for a plumber. I chose South West because A) I remembered them from heavy TV ads (that shoulda been my first clue) and B) there was a coupon in the phone book for $39 off any plumbing job. I called and the receptionist was extremely friendly. I wanted them to come out the next day, and I chose a time window of 1:30 to 3:30.
They showed up early, by about a half an hour. That was OK with me. Like others mentioned, there were two of them, a journeyman and an apprentice. The journeyman confirmed with me that I was having problems with the disposal, and I told him I was sure it was fried. He said, well, maybe not. It could be jammed, and I SWEAR I heard him say that they wouldn't charge me if that were the case. So he got under the sink and showed me that there was an allen wrench attached to the side of the disposal, and all I had to do was stick it in a hole in the bottom of the disposal and twist, and that would unjam it. So *I* did as he told me. (Yep, I did the WORK). And wouldn't you know it, I switched on the disposal and voila! It worked.
So I thought that was it, and I was happy I wouldn't have to pay anything. Not even a call-out fee (which I expected). BUT WAIT. He said that by the sound of the disposal, he could tell it was on it's way out, and perhaps, since they were already there, they might as well replace it, so I wouldn't have to call them out again in the future. I said, well, OK, and asked him how much it would be. He brought out the EVIL BOOK, and gee, the prices for disposers was right there on the first page. Hm. He said the best disposal to get would be a 3/4 HP that was very powerful and had a 3 year warranty (although he said the disposal would also last as long as my current one). Price? $1000!! I told him I didn't really need a disposal that would chew up rocks, since I put most of my food scraps in the compost bucket anyway. So I asked how much a cheaper disposal would be. There was only one other option.....the cheaper disposal was $795 not counting labor. Ha.......I knew that top of the line disposals didn't cost anymore than about $350 or so.
Then he got sort of patronizing toward me. He insisted I needed that 3/4 HP. I said I really didn't have the funds to pay $1000 for a disposal, but thank you anyway. He then kept pressuring me, and I could totally tell he was out of plumbing mode and heavily into upsell mode. I kept saying no, that I would deal with my old disposal as long as it worked, and then think about replacing it later. He kept at me, and I almost was at the point where I was going to say, please get the hell out of my mother's house. I kept politely saying no, and he finally gave up. So THEN he gets out his invoice book. So I asked him, are you charging me a call-out fee? And he said no, it's $200 to unjam a disposal. Huh? I twisted the stupid allen wrench; *I* should be getting $200, not HIM. And I KNOW (well I think I know) that I heard him say the unjamming the unit was free. I bit my tongue and wrote out a check for $200. Yeah. $200 to tell me to twist an allen wrench. RIP OFF.
After they left I did some research online. I found disposals that had more HP than 3/4 for MUCH less than $795 or for that matter, $1000. I realized the prices he quoted me were more than 100% mark up!! I actually tried to find disposals that cost more than $795. I didn't find any.
LIke the others, I can say they were polite, professional, attentive and very friendly. But that doesn't make up for totally ripping people off.
So.......my husby will be coming out to Mom's in the next couple weeks and he'll be installing a $99 disposal for free.