I would not recommend them for a tile roof at all.
Came out and did a small tile roof repair for me. They told told me what a great job they did, and I paid them. The price was TRIPLE any other reputable company, by the way. The bids I have for repair of a 70 square area are in the $500 range. This company was triple that. I wanted to believe they would do a really great job on my roof and would have no further issues for many years from the roof. I just wanted it done right. Unfortunately, what I got from this company was completely the opposite.
I foolishly did not personally inspect the roof before they left. I took their word for it that the job was done correctly, and completely as specified. The only criteria I specified was NO roofing felt or tar paper under the area of this small 18 tile area of repair. I specified metal, or a membrane like Peel and Stick'. I should have asked for SBS or one of the newer, far more durable membranes, but I did not know any better and it was certainly not suggested.
A later roof inspection revealed many issues. 14 roof tiles were floating on my roof, neither nailed or adhered in any way. The roof was missing 4 tiles altogether, many tiles were cut incorrectly, far too short. There were large gaps, (2-4 inches) between the hip ridge and the next tile down. In other words, tiles were were not placed to catch water coming off the hip ridge, at all. The missing tiles and the tiles that were cut off too short clearly showed the old damaged roofing felt, (tar paper). This made me very angry. I had CLEARLY specified the whole area was to either have peel and stick or metal protecting the roof decking, and I had been told the roof was done to my specifications, clearly a lie. They basically left the old, crappy and damaged tar paper up there and hoped I would never notice.
Update: They have since come out and corrected their work. But they argued with me every step of the way. They said that the 18 roof tiles were just fine sitting on the roof with out nails or adhesive. They argued and insisted the 4 missing tiles were never on my roof to begin with, but this is a lie. My roof was never missing tiles. I believe they were damaged by cutting, and they thought no one would notice them missing. The 4 tiles they replaced are a completely different color, and at some point I will have them changed out by a reputable roofer. They argued and said the old damaged tar paper was just fine as well, even though It had a hole in it and was starting to disintegrate.
Although they did come out and correct the work, I felt like each step was a negotiation, with a lot of out right lies, mis-leading statements, and blame on other people thrown in. I would rather have a company who does it right the first time. I also prefer companies who do not argue or lie, (Roofing felt for tile roofs is special roofing paper (No, it's not, it just 30lb run-of-the-mill roofing paper) and my favorite was, Tiles do not have to be nailed or glued on a roof, they are fine being held by their back lip WTF? Umm, OK, call me crazy, but do you think you could just nail or glue mine PLEASE? My favorite quote was from the owner, Chris. He literally told me to get up on the roof myself and check that the redone job was to my satisfaction. Again, wtf ??? Because, as he put it, he had no intention to drive out and look at my job again because it take too much time.
No, I would not recommend them. I want someone who does the job right the first time.