Had an unsatisfying experience with Durham Plumbing Services recently. We had a number of small plumbing issues to take care of and I was using them as a rehearsal of sorts before finalizing a plumber to pull a permit to do our kitchen reno work.
We had them replace a leaking bathroom faucet. Just a typical leak caught and draining through the basin. We will be renovating our upstairs bathrooms within 3-10 years, so it didn't make sense to me to invest in an expensive faucet. I thought a decently reviewed Home Depot house brand would be sufficient.
By the end of the evening, we knew we wouldn't hire them for the additional work. We didn't feel like they were respectful of our choices and that there was a whole lot more talking than doing. But that sort of personality conflict would not have inspired me to leave a negative review.
However, the way they treated us when we found out that the faucet had been leaking for weeks into our sink cabinet, damaging both the walls and the vanity, has inspired me to share my experience. I called them initially because of positive reviews on sites like this one. So I feel like I should warn others.
Basically, the plumbers claimed 'It's not leaking,' when we called them back in. They said the damage must have already been there. When we provided video proof, 'Can't look at it this week, things are too crazy, catch you several days from now.' As we are catching drips in a bucket. (Their side: The manager says that since we didn't want to deal with the initial crew that the delay was unavoidable.) And then finally, when the manager came to look at the issue, he blamed the faucet. 'Not me, not us, not responsible.' Now, if the faucet was broken to begin with, shouldn't an experienced plumber have seen that during installation? How do we know that they didn't over-tighten it or handle it in some way that led to it breaking. How does the flow from a couple of weeks of tooth-brushing cause a faucet to spontaneously crack?
In my opinion, when you do business with pros, there are a lot of gray areas. At one end of that area, he's right, 'We didn't warranty your faucet, would not have recommended it, therefore we aren't responsible.' Even though we discovered the issues within a month of the installation, and the leak had obviously started well before that. Would he have dealt with it if we had discovered the leak two hours later? The next day?
But from my end of the gray area, we hired licensed pros for a job and achieved a result we could have gotten if we had saved ourselves the hundreds of dollars they charged for the installation and gone with a youtube video DIY approach. A busted vanity, water damaged walls, and a sink that has the water shut off to it. And now we have to find another plumber to take on the task. At least before, with the faucet leak, we were only losing money to our water bill.
Many times, a business will meet you somewhere in the middle. Maybe offer to install a new faucet for free if we paid for it. Or offer to refund some of or the whole initial installation fee. All the way up to covering all the damage. I'm southern, so I might hear, Well, how about this ... or This is what I'll do ... But that didn't happen. They're happier 'being right' than at least working with their customer to achieve a neutral outcome. Given the amount of money we're out and the damage we have to deal with, I think Durham Plumbing got the better end of the deal with this dissatisfied review. But hey, other people appear to be happy customers, so maybe we are just really, really unlucky.
(They say: It is unfair to blame us for a faulty faucet. That they did the work correctly.) I say I would have been satisfied with a system that didn't leak. Take from this review what you will.
By the way: the faucet gets 4 out of 5 stars on Home Depot's site and 83% of buyers recommend it. Some do have problems. Some also find ways to fix the problems. No such attempts were made by the reviewed plumbers.
Tl;dr Maybe they're good plumbers when things go well but if something goes wrong, have fun with the chest-thumping 'Gotta be right,' attitude. And the complete lack of resolution of the issues.