Debi P.
01/11/2012 12:00:00 SA
If you're really considering O'Neill Plumbing, make sure you read all of the filtered reviews for the true picture. Do not rely on the stars on the first page, or the 22 good reviews showing - only 7 are even from this year. Of the 98 filtered reviews, 25 are mostly current 1-star ratings with disaster stories.
I'm baffled by all of the 5 star ratings and applause for coming back 3, 4 ,5 times - Don't you want someone who can do it right the first time?
I called based on the the 5 stars, didn't read the other reviews, huge mistake. My shower didn't work, water only coming out of the tub faucet, I wanted it fixed quickly. $150 to come out, fine, should be easy. I had to take a picture and send it in, so they could make sure they had the parts on the truck. Right.
Josh arrived, took a 2 second look, then immediately went looking around the pipes, and told me I should rebuild the whole thing for $425, and could pay 1/2 today. How about you go see what the actual problem is before upselling me. And why would I pay 1/2 down today for anything? I should have asked him to leave at this point.
Josh attempted to remove the shower handle, gets out a big wrench and says I'm going to scuff this up. Ok, you're going to leave marks, fine. 30 seconds later the handle has been broken off, shearing off the shower diverter tip with it. Josh says he's not responsible for this, (You broke it, who else would be responsible?), says he warned me it would break, and I authorized it (No, you did not, you were going to scratch it). They do not have the part on the truck of course, but he'll find it, they'll call me soon.
He was arrogant enough to place an O'Neill Plumbing magnet on my refrigerator sometime during his visit, which I found later. Who touches people's stuff like that? Hand me the thing, don't touch things in my house. I'm pointing that out to relay the arrogant, direspectful tone of this business, from it's owner to it's employees.
4 weeks later no one had called, I call them again and get a return call from the infamous Shannon. Based on all the 5 star reviews, and not having read the hidden reviews, I think I'm in good hands, the owner is going to get this fixed up.
Not. Shannon was combative from the start, they can't find the part, what do I want to do. Well, what are my options? They can rebuild it all, or maybe there's a generic part. Not that they'd tried to locate said generic part, which is what Josh said he would do.
After being pleasant and hopeful this would get resolved by the owner, then getting his attitude, and being left hanging for a month, I said I wasn't so happy I'd paid $150 for Josh to break my shower handle and now they can't find the part to fix it. Shannon lost what little composure he had and became truly horrible, launched a screaming, unprofessional tirade: 9 out of 10 handles break, he's glad this happened because he's not working on faucets any more, he didn't have to work for me, he's going to post on Yelp he doesn't work on faucets, etc.
Turns out the actual problem was the shower head, which I identified and replaced myself (should have checked that before calling, live and learn - but I'm not the plumber). I said it was too bad they didn't check that first instead of going straight for dismantling the shower, and got another tirade about telling him how to do plumbing.
Actually during this rant he asked me if I told my hairstylist how to do my hair. Yes, of course I tell them what I want. No, Shannon just tells them to make him look good, and evidently you're supposed to give them free reign in your house for whatever they want to do, and don't question them, because they are doing you a favor by taking your business. If anything goes wrong, good luck to you - problem resolution is usually a mark of a good business - that's not here.
He said he'd send my $150 back, since they advertise they stand behind their work. No refund ever happened.
They do not stand behind their work, they try to intimidate, yell, upsell, nasty business and nasty behavior, completely unprofessional. I ended up having to yell over Shannon that I was ending our conversation and hang up.
Dealing with them was a complete hassle and very unpleasant. I would report them to the BBB, but I'd have to deal with them again, which is not going to happen.
I called a real plumber, who had the part the next day, installed, $125, hassle free.
Call ANY other plumber than these guys.