UPDATE: **In response to the owner's reply to me, saying that I was fabricating this, I have edited a bit of this response. I do have a receipt from the job, so I know I paid a bit over $300. However, because this is a tenant occupied home, I had forgotten that the tenants also had the plumber look at something else. Therefore, in fairness, I do not know how much was charged for the toilet fix itself, or if there was a weekend surcharge. I only have the total bill (electronic, with no breakdown). I have deleted my comments about cost.
But what I DO know, for a fact, is this:
1. The toilet that MSK fixed started leaking again, for the same reason, a year later.
2. I now have wood damage under the toilet, that wasn't there a year ago.
3. Another plumber completely disagrees with how MSK fixed the toilet the first time.
4. I was told by MSK that the whole toilet flange had to be replaced because it was too low (not because it was broken)....and another plumber said that was NOT necessary.
I tend to believe the new plumber because the flange has been there for 15 years with no problem, as long as the wax rings are properly installed.
These are facts.
Also, for the record:
5. I have no reason to be fabricating anything about a plumber. I have better things to do.
6. MSK replied that he is suspicious about the validity of my reviews because I wrote another plumbing review a month ago. FYI: that plumbing issue was AT A DIFFERENT HOUSE that I also own, and I gave that plumber 5 stars. So I am not here trying to viciously attack plumbers! I've had a lot of plumbing issues, and it is very frustrating finding good help. So I write reviews either when I have an extremely good experience, or a very bad one.
7. I'd have been more impressed if MSK had just written sorry your toilet started leaking again, please give us another chance to make it right rather than accusing me of fabricating stories about their service.
________________________
This review has something rather important in plumbing: FOLLOW-UP. And, unfortunately, it is NOT good followup.
MSK Plumbing fixed a leaking toilet in my 1930s house about a year ago. The problem was due to a degraded wax ring. I now rent the house out, so the tenants called MSK Plumbing after we found them on Yelp.
Of course this had to happen on a Saturday. MSK DID show up the next day, Sunday, and so that part was great. They coordinated with my tenant, to her schedule, showed up on time, fixed it, and sent the bill to me.
It was not a totally standard situation because the toilet flange sits lower than usual, due to it being a very old house. Therefore, two wax rings are necessary.
The MSK plumber told us that he installed two rings, but told me that the flange should be elevated. I didn't entirely understand this, because I had lived in that house for 15 years, with the toilet just as it was, double wax rings and whatever, and I never had a leak...
The bill was around $300 (I have the receipt) but my tenants also had him look at a leaking tub faucet/shower, so I am not sure how much of that was for the toilet fix. Mostly I was relieved to have my tenants happy.
But fast forward about 1 year: my tenants call and say that same toilet is leaking. Ugh.
This time I called a different plumber...
This new plumber coordinated with my tenants for the repair (same tenants) and then called to discuss with me. I told him I just paid to fix the same toilet about a year ago, and prior to that, had had NO problems for the 15 years that I had lived in the house, despite the same double stacked wax ring issue. I asked him if it was the flange.
This new plumber told me (in detailed terms that I won't bother retelling) that the previous fix was not correctly done. He also told me the flange was NOT a problem, so no other repair was necessary.
But worst of all, I now have wood damage under the toilet, which was NOT there a year ago. I hate it when I have to pay the price for someone else's mistake.....
In fairness, I guess I should wait a year to see if this new repair holds up.
But before you believe all the 5 star reviews MSK gets on Yelp, realize that it is NOT only about whether the plumber answers the phone, shows up and is nice and fixes your issue. (although that is much appreciated and admittedly sometimes hard to find, esp on a weekend).
It's about whether that repair was done the RIGHT way...and I give MSK 1 star on that. Now I might have to pull up tiles on my floor, or open up the ceiling underneath the water damage that occurred after MSK's fix.
:(