After requesting help and quotes on Yelp for a low water pressure situation in an upstairs bath/shower with two faucets (the guest bath) that had apparently occurred within the last two months, Joe came by to give a free estimate. This was at my mother-in-law's house where my wife and I are staying while her mother recovers from surgery. To diagnose the problem, and after turning off the water at the street, he took out both valves and stuck a wire into the connecting pipe to see if there was any sediment or buildup but nothing was apparent. He reinstalled the valves but there wasn't any improvement. He gave us a quote for a single-control Moen temperature-balancing faucet, complete with a trim plate that would cover the holes left by the original faucets, for $325. Now that he had diagnosed the problem, he urged us to ask for quotes for this job on Yelp to see what others would charge. We were fine with this estimate but had other plumbers coming and wanted at least a second opinion. But Joe didn't charge for this initial diagnosis.
Two hours later, another plumber responding to our request on Yelp showed up. I didn't tell him what Joe had done previously. This time we turned off the water using the valve in the garage, the only difference. He pretty much determined the same problem but wanted $150 to remove the valves and fish the connecting pipe. I pressed him on what the next step would be if that didn't work (which I already knew it wouldn't). He said that he could install pretty much the same single-control faucet that Joe had recommended for $600-$800! I then told him that Joe had already done what he wanted $150 to do and also told him Joe's estimate for the same type of faucet. He was amazed and asked if Joe was a real plumber and he kept pressing and pressing and I told him, no, I wasn't interested, I thanked him for his time and effort but told him that I was ending this. He protested all the way out the door and then told me he might be able to do it on his time for less. No thanks!
But wait, here's the best part! After he left, I turned on all the faucets in the house and then opened the valve in the garage. Lots of noise and banging and the sound of water whooshing. I started to turn off all the faucets downstairs and my wife called from upstairs saying that water was gushing out of the tub spout in the upstairs bathroom! Apparently, whatever Joe did had resolved the problem, it just took a complete flushing of the faucets and the upstairs bath/shower was now working just fine. My wife and I finally got to take decent showers again!
Since Joe actually fixed the problem and it didn't cost her anything, my mother-in-law decided that she wanted to reimburse him for his time and effort, so she called and said that she wanted to send a check for $100. A very nice woman (Joe's wife?) answered and when she explained the call to Joe, they both said that this wasn't necessary. If we have any future plumbing problem at either my mother-in-law's house or at our house, we will definitely call Joe!