Tom L.
08/09/2021 12:00:00 SA
On August 3rd, we contacted Peachtree Plumbing & Drain to fix a leaky toilet. The plumber came on August 4 and performed a partial rebuild for $300, which did not fix the leak. During that visit, the plumber indicated he would need a custom tank gasket and would order it. We own a 2001 Kohler Santa Rosa, for which parts are readily available. The plumber installed some new parts and left, asking us not to use the toilet and telling us he would return with the custom gasket and would charge us nothing for installation.
The customer service representative called to schedule the second visit and sought to charge us $100 for that visit. We informed her that the plumber told us there would be no charge for further service. The plumber visited for follow-up without the custom part and instead installed a separate gasket that did not seal to the tank, and threw out the previous part. The toilet leaked worse than before and was rendered unusable for the next five days.
After that second visit, the owner of Peach Plumbing & Drain spoke to us vowing to fix the problem. We did not see another customer service representative for three days after that phone call. The toilet was unusable still.
When that plumber appeared this afternoon, he indicated that because our toilet was old, that it was not fixable without the custom part. He also indicated he still had not ordered the custom part - but if we wanted, he would glue the gasket to the tank, which, he acknowledged, was still unlikely to stop the leak. He recommended we replace the entire toilet, then returned to his car outside. While he was outside, I ordered the correct part online for $6.00.
Today is Monday 8/9/2021; the part will arrive 8/14/2021. The plumber re-entered our home one last time to reiterate the unfixability of the toilet without that part. He advised us again to buy an entirely new toilet and that once we did that we could schedule a time for Peach Plumbing & Drain to install it We informed him that we had ordered the right part while he was waiting outside in his car. We also informed him when the part would arrive. He said great. It sounds like everything is taken care of, did not offer to return to install it, and left.
From top to bottom, this was the worst quality service we ever received for any home-related service. They failed to fix a problem but instead worsened it. It took them multiple trips, each one delaying a solution and stretching out the problem. They repeatedly attempted to charge us more money or require work that wasn't required. Then they left - even when we had the part and therefore the solution in-hand - and offered no additional support or follow-up.
I took video of the work after the first visit. It is amazing to me that the toilet was left in that condition.