I am a bit on the fence. I had a leak coming from under my foundation. I worked with Tom to try and diagnose the issue and I was on the same page as he was as to what the problem was. It was clear from my initial conversation that he was very knowledge, been in the area a very long time, friendly, and knew what he was doing. After the initial inspection, he left with a promise to have it fixed tomorrow. I did find it odd that he would not give me a solid estimate for the fix.
The next day, the plumber came and did the repair we discussed. He did a good job at it and there were no leaks coming from his new PEX plumbing he ran to bypass the line underground. He was here under 2 hours and the cost was six hundred dollars. This was a high price tag, especially without giving me a warning the day before, but I was happy to have it working and did not make a complaint.
The problem started two hours later when I saw that the problem had not been resolved and there was still water coming out of the foundation into the bedroom. Both Tom and I had guess wrong as to what the problem was. It was a tricky leak for sure. The plumber said that he would have Tom call me to see what they can do.
The reason for the 3 stars is that he did not call me. I am assuming that going back and trying to investigate why the initial fix didn't work is difficult but I was ultimately left to diagnose the problem myself and find another person to help resolve.