I have 5 rental homes that need to be completely updated and remodeled (kitchens, baths, flooring, painting, new fixtures) and am ready to start on the first one now with the others to follow serially upon completion.
After finding this firm here and on Angie's List, with their consistently good reviews on both sites, I called and spoke with Mike the owner who referred me to his estimator Tom. After some phone tag, Tom came out (on time) to do the estimate. Tom within a few minutes became quite disinterested in the job stating that since I had already picked out tile, vanities, some fixtures (but NOT kitchen cabinets, countertops, many fixtures, etc.) there was not enough profit margin in it for his firm and they did not do mostly labor and supplies projects. (He also said they did not really do flips'. I told them these were rentals of my father who passed recently and that my sister and I would be keeping them but wanted to update them.)
Anyway, I was surprised by his lack of interest because when I described the job to the owner, I was not told that they primarily supply (and mark up) purchases with their remodeling- after all, I was not in need of an interior design firm. And despite having 4 other houses to remodel, he just was not interested in basic contractor work unless they could sell most of the materials and so he declined to proceed looking at the house after a few minutes and said he was not interested and would not bid. Only later after reading some reviews on Angie's List did I find I was not the only potential customer to be told this after the fact.
In trying to find a contractor for these projects, I did run into firms with a similar business model yet was told this fact at the initial inquiry thereby revealing that we would not be a good fit business-wise. I wish McCurdy would have done the same as better initial communication would have saved us the both time and expense of a pointless meeting.
Clearly, given the reviews, this firm does good work at presumably acceptable prices and for those who need a turn-key, full service design and build approach, McCurdy should be considered. For others like myself who do not need that much design help and wish to have a wider choice of materials at a less marked up price, there are other firms that are a better match.