TL/DR; Two tasks were needed. One was priced fair but high and the other the technician made a mistake. But Ace plumbing made it right.
I left a voicemail and sent an email to Ace for 1) a Washer hot water shutoff valve leaking by with the hose stuck on there and 2) a dripping Moen shower faucet. I received a call back from Josh looking to schedule a guy to come out that day. Not being able to accommodate and coordinate such a quick availability, Josh communicated with me via text to schedule an appointment a couple days out.
The technician, Jason, was available early and arrived early to the rental property, they did wait with little issue for my wife to arrive on time and let him in. He quickly took a look at the two areas and gave me a price over the phone of $325 for to replace the whole washer valve box and 450 for the upstairs faucet. I was surprised and disappointed when he said he had to replace the whole faucet. I did research ahead of time and had actually planned to replace the Moen cartridge myself, he said he could not identify the faucet (even though I did) so didn't quote that option. Since I had already bought the cartridge, I asked if he can just replace it. He said he can try and it would be $150 (high in my mind, but fair) if it works and $50 if it doesn't.
I gave approval for both jobs. He completed the faucet cartridge change in like 5 minutes (according to my wife) so the price was definitely high. I say it's fair though because it could have been seized in there and taken longer. Business have to quote high here and there to ensure they maintain a profit over all jobs by expecting some to have issues.
For the Washer, they did confirm that they needed to cut off the hose that was stuck on there. Unfortunately, Jason cut off both hoses, where the good one was actually property of the tenant. I understand that this was an honest mistake to be efficient but, in my opinion, was still wrong on his part. I communicate the issue to Josh and they agreed to replace the incorrectly cut hose.
My research shows $325 was a fair price for this job. Both jobs I consider high priced because Toledo is a low cost of living area, but I would rather pay fair/high for good service and a company who stands behind their work than one who doesn't.
Overall, I would use this company again.