J B.
03/03/2015 12:00:00 SA
Last winter, the shut-off valve that leads to the outside faucet on the front of my hose failed. So, despite the fact that I had closed the valve and drained that pipe, a small amount of water leaked through the rubber gasket. That water froze and the pipe leading to the faucet exploded. The water runs along the wall between the garage and the foyer and water flooded into both areas. I had to tear out the drywall and insulation, replace the molding, and repaint both areas.
Cropp Metcalfe's technician, Nasir, tells me how he can just repair the valve by replacing a rubber washer. I questioned that, because it wouldn't be that much more trouble to replace the entire thing rather than taking the valve apart and replacing one part. But, he was in a rush (a lot of pipes burst that weekend) and he said he would only replace the washer.
Maybe I should have known better, but I didn't ask him to write out the cost before he started work. Before he started, he told me it would cost a certain amount. When he was done and gave me the invoice, it was $50 more. He told me I must have misheard him, but I know what I heard. Virginia law requires all licensed contractors have a written contract before they begin working, so you are well within your rights to insist on that. Here was another problem - he didn't write on the invoice that he'd repaired the valve - remember that. He did the work and rushed away - I paid $358 for an hour of labor and about $30 materials.
This winter, the pipe broke and sprayed water again. It popped apart at the place where Cropp repaired it. I was shocked because I had closed the valve and drained the pipe (at the faucet and the bleed valve) before it got cold. I called Croppe because any repairs would be covered by warranty. When the new technician came out, he didn't know Cropp had repaired the valve because it wasn't written on my invoice. I told him someone replaced the washer the previous winter, and he quickly said something along the lines of, Oh, no, you can't do that, you can't repair those things. You never repair it, you just replace it. He said it's pretty much impossible to replace the washer in one of those valves and have it work correctly. He said the washer failed (again) this winter and let water into the pipe and the pipe froze when it got cold.
I told him that Cropp had been the ones to replace the washer instead of replacing the valve and he said that they hadn't, because it wasn't written on the invoice. He said it would be my word against theirs, which made me pretty angry because I don't appreciate someone coming into MY house and calling me a liar. I told him that because I had been dealing with the insurance company last time, I took pictures of everything, including the Cropp plumber replacing the washer. At this point, he said he had to go out to his van to write up an estimate for the work. Then, he got in his van and drove away.
Before he ran away, he told me he would charge another four hundred dollars to fix it. He also said that he could only do it for that price because he wasn't going to write everything on the invoice, so he could charge me less. That seems to be the standard practice at Cropp, they charge you a ridiculous fee and claim to discount it by not writing everything down on the invoice. Then when something goes wrong they'll deny having done the work in the first place. I asked him why they would charge me four hundred dollars to re-do work that they didn't do correctly the first time, and that was when he called me a liar and stormed out. The worst part is that it wouldn't have cost any more to have it fixed right the first time.
The day after Cropp called me a liar and ran away, I called to talk to a manager. It took four calls to get one on the phone. The manager, Allan Oddenino, refused to take responsibility for any of Cropp's mistakes. He couldn't explain why the pipe had popped apart and refused to honor any type of warranty on his company's work. He admitted that his employees had made mistakes. He admitted that the valve had failed and that it should have been replaced instead of repaired. However, he claimed there were too many variables for him to take responsibility for what his employees did.
I was floored. Cropp did a bad job and a pipe that they replaced broke the next winter! I had to tear out the drywall and destroy the garage again. Water poured into the foyer and I might have to replace all that molding again. I think they know they can thumb their nose at me because they're a big company and they know I can't actually hold them accountable. So, if you're looking for a company that will call you a liar, do a rushed job that doesn't actually fix the problem, and then literally run away and hide when you dare to complain, you should go with Cropp Metcalfe. There's a reason this company has such bad reviews. If you're looking for a company that stands by its work, look elsewhere.