Isaiah S.
11/05/2020 12:00:00 SA
I asked Hughes Mechanical for a quote for replacement of (7) decades-old gate-type water valves, including the main water shutoff to the house, and installation of (2) new valves where a shower had never been provided with shutoff valves. There was also some miscellaneous adjustment work. I obtained quotes from (3) other plumbers, all small or family-owned businesses. Hughes Mechanical was either cheaper or about the same price.
I chose Hughes because they use on online system for providing you a work summary/quote (I prefer written documentation of all communications/commitments) and they utilized my own work summary (Word documentation listing all the desired work and providing photos) to prepare their quote summary.
I was absent for the work and a family member stood in. I found out after I got home that they had not replaced the angle stop valves with the type I specified (quarter-turn ball valves) but with multi-turn compression valves. Additionally, the main water shutoff valve had not been replaced, but a new valve installed after it on the same line. However, they had performed additional work beyond the work summary to replace some old pipe in a crawlspace which connected to on of the valves in the house.
After I objected, they scheduled a follow-up visit and replaced all valves as originally requested. They explained that there was water coming out of the pipes on their first visit and the valve stock in their truck could not be soldered on (before the second visit I drained the pipes 12 hours in advance). I can understand that in my absence they chose to install the valves they had on hand, and they did follow up to address. However, during the second visit, the plumber said the code standard is for the main water line to have (2) valves so there is a backup. This means that when I specifically asked that the main water valve be replaced, they added (1) new valve and left the old valve untouched to be the second valve for code, neglecting my replacement request to save time.
I'll give 5 stars as the extra work balances skipping the water main valve replacement and the returned to install the valves as I originally requested. I do recommend that you make sure your work request is detailed and sent via email so you have written record.