I am giving Bayshore Plumbing one star not because of the quality of the plumber's work, which was very neat, but because of what we were not told was a viable repair option at the time of service.
The job was simple: remove our broken toilet bowl and replace it with a new, one-piece toilet. Only the bowl was sitting on the floor when the plumber arrived - we had already removed the tank, as it was the part that broke. The plumber, Dan, only had to remove the two bolts holding down the toilet, lift it off, clean up a little, put on a new wax ring, and lower the new toilet onto the bolts. The old toilet did not wobble at all, and the bolts were secure in the floor, so I was a little surprised when Dan told me that one side of the flange had a small tear in it, and he doubted the bolt would fasten securely. Not sure when this tear occurred - possibly when he lifted the old bowl up? No way of knowing that. Anyway, Dan asked me if I wish to install a new flange, which would entail cutting, gluing, waiting for the glue to dry, etc - at least another hour's work, if not 90 minutes.
At this point he hadn't said that the bolt would not tighten AT ALL, merely that it might not be as secure as I would like, and I opted not to do the extra repair. As it turned out, when he lowered the toilet onto the new bolts, the one on the left did not tighten - in fact, it lifted right out, but I didn't find this out until after he had left, when I removed the cap to look underneath.
Dan thought perhaps the caulk, together with the one bolt, would hold the toilet down, if we weren't too rough on it and gave the caulk a few days to mature.
So here is my beef: NEVER ONCE did he mention that there was a simple repair in the form of a flange saver, an inexpensive metal part that is commonly used in cases such as these, when the flange is essentially good, but needs a little repair. I discovered this part after Googling flange repair.
When I called Bayshore this morning to voice my complaint, I was told by a very nice employee named Andy (Andie?) that the Master Plumber considered a flange saver nothing but a Band-Aid, and that is why Dan had not offered us the option.
Regardless of what the Master Plumber considers a proper toilet installation, a flange saver that would have held down the second bolt would certainly be a preferable solution to what we have now - one bolt and caulking - to hold our toilet secure. And he certainly should have told us about this BEFORE the job was finished.
I would happily pay for a flange saver and new wax ring if Bayshore Plumbing would send someone back to put it on for us, but that is not going to happen. It was not even offered.
I will not use this company again, even though they were highly recommended by a dear friend. Too bad - I was intending to refer them to my wide circle of friends and clients, all of whom are always looking for a dependable and honest plumber. I guess repeat business is not important to Bayshore Plumbing. They have lost a good referral source in me.